Movies Like Barney's Version (2010)

Staff & contributors

Chasing the feel of watching Barney's Version ? Here are the movies we recommend you watch right after.

When a film is about a person, most depictions would be presented in the best possible light, all to present them as a person to be admired. That being said, Barney’s Version does not do that. The novel does give the adaptation some trouble– after all, Barney is a guy that fell in love with a woman other than his wife on his wedding night– but while Barney isn’t exactly the best person you’d like to meet, the way the story is structured, Paul Giamatti’s sympathetic performance and the way Barney remains honest with himself and his desires all throughout life makes the title character easy to root for, even with all his blunt ways. Barney’s Version does take plenty of familiar tropes, sometimes stereotypical, but it handles this life drama with subtle comedy and excellent performances.

It’s not fair to say if you’ve read the book, you’ve seen the movie, but it’s also not wholly untrue. Greg Sinise’s version of the classic tale by John Steinback adds little new details to the story, so the actors have some heavy lifting to do in bringing it to life. Thankfully, they do a fine job. Sinise and Malkovich strike an affecting camaraderie, believable till its tragic end. Malkovich has the meatiest role as the mentally challenged Lennie, and to his credit, he gives the character sensitivity and grace. He isn’t always believable (or maybe I’ve just seen him in too many wry and manipulative roles), but his turn as a sweet giant is always touching. For a more recent generation, the film might bring to mind the ethical question famously asked by the NBC series The Good Place: what do we owe each other? What does George owe his disabled cousin and how far is he willing to put his life over his own? Though the parable at the core of this film is familiar, it’s nonetheless thought-provoking and heartbreaking.

Genre: Drama

Actor: Alexis Arquette, Casey Siemaszko, David Steen, Gary Sinise, Joe D'Angerio, Joe Morton, John Malkovich, John Terry, Mark Boone Junior, Moira Sinise, Noble Willingham, Ray Walston, Richard Riehle, Sherilyn Fenn, Tuck Milligan

Director: Gary Sinise

Rating: PG-13